we mean it, man
Yet more evidence that people who write for broadsheet newspapers have less understanding of popular music than almost any other sub-species of human being: Sunday's
Observer described Pink as
"the husky voice of authenticity".
Uh-
huh.
Don't missundaztand me here: yes, on one level this is a ridiculous statement just because Pink is clearly not "the husky voice of authenticity" by any means. But what really gets my goat is the fact that dumb-ass, boring journalists still feel the need to attach such an ill-fitting epithet to a pop star. This is the flipside of those radio stations in the UK that (allegedly) didn't playlist 'Hurt' because they haven't yet grasped the fact that the kids might be into ol' Johnny Cash (who I guess
was the husky voice of authenticity) rather than just wall-to-wall pop shinyness. Which is to say, it's being so narrow-minded that you can't accept more than one type of music or artist on its own terms - you have to either exclude things that don't fit into your little hermeneutical definitions, or distort shit wildly so you can pretend one thing is the other.
It all goes back to the fact that supposedly progressive newspapers like the
Guardian / Observer almost always struggle to engage with pop music in a way that isn't reactionary. Weirdly, it seems that the perceived high/low divide has been eroded much more successfully in the written discourse that surrounds other media: trashy TV can be celebrated, big noisy summer blockbusters can be celebrated... But certain types of popular music? Well, by and large they have to be handled in an insidiously specific way.
So for hip-hop the formula is something like "most rap music is about X and Y (bad, scary things!), but not this artist!" - because you can't give the culture the respect it deserves, rather you portray one specific individual as a lone messiah figure. It doesn't matter how ridiculously inaccurate or contradictory the results may be - eg if you're writing about Missy, you have to say that she redeemed rap from being macho and obsessed with violence, but if it's Eminem then you have to go on about how gritty he is and how that's much better than talking about partying on yachts and the bling bling.
With straight-up chart pop, what happens is even more weirdly arbitrary: you say "unlike Cristina or Britney, Pink's not just pretending to be dirrty or jumping on bandwagons, she really means it and she's in control!" - and then when you have to run a Kylie interview, you just flip the names round and say "unlike weak rebellious poseurs like Pink, Kylie is the real deal!" and JESUS CHRIST ENOUGH ALREADY. Just say it. Say "I like chart pop done by female vocalists." Say it! Or if you don't like it, God I'd almost rather you just joined the Hatrix and just never covered it, y'know? Because I cannot cope with this need to strip the fun away from something in order to try to impose the ill-fitting concept of serious artistic credibility, a concept that's been looking shoddy for just under a century...
And which would you rather be anyway, the husky voice of authenticity or dressed up as the devil like something off the nose of a WWII bomber complete with ridiculous huge blonde hair extensions (and cage)? And OH SHIT why can't we get our head round the idea that people can be both? I'd love to see The Detroit Cobras rock the devil costume thing, they're pretty much there already with that ridiculous
Seven Easy Pieces cover art. In fact, The Distillers - there's your bundle of contradictions right there - Brody, the husky voice of authentic (punk rock) media manipulation and hype -
and we don't caaaaaare...
The above interview ends with Pink pretty much making it explicit that she doesn't care either:
"Yeah, maybe I'll write the next album on my own. Maybe with Dolly Parton. Who knows?"
Anyway… ‘Trouble’ has really grown on me. I think it’s the way it has this smoked-too-many-fags, anyone-fancy-a-splash-of-vino-colapso quality to it - it's not proper punk, it's a pop song for people who overdo it now and again, which is fine and really far more human. And I can't help group it in my mind with the Distillers track...